Preheat your oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit.
Mix the ingredients until it forms a thick dough. You want the dough to have a drier consistency. If it feels sticky, add a little bit of flour.
Sprinkle some flour on your countertop before you place your dough down so that it doesn’t stick. I added some basil and oregano to my dough because I want to use my hardtack in soups and stews. Just knead it into the dough a little bit to mix it through. You could also add dry ingredients to the flour ahead of time, if you prefer.
Using a rolling pin, roll out your dough until it is about ½ inch thick or even a little thinner. Make sure it is as even as possible so that your wafers will cook evenly.
Cut your dough into cracker-like squares. If you’re feeling creative, you could use cookie cutters to create interesting shapes, although this isn’t necessary at all. The more uniform the size and shape, the better the hardtack will bake. I don’t worry too much about how my hardtack looks, but I do like to make smaller, thinner cracker-sized pieces. I used a pizza cutter to cut my dough, but you could use a knife or spatula. Just make sure you cut it before you bake it.
Place your raw hardtack on an ungreased cookie sheet and poke holes into each piece with a toothpick.
Your wafers should be evenly browned. You can remove them from the oven and place them on a cooling rack or turn off the oven and leave them to cool in the oven itself. The idea is to remove as much moisture as possible without burning the hardtack. This will help your hardtack store for longer.
Store your hardtack away from moisture. I like to put mine in mason jars. Hardtack with no add-ins should last indefinitely under the right storage conditions.
To use your hardtack, soak it for 10 minutes in milk, coffee, soup, or even water. I am using mine to thicken up some chicken broth and to add extra calories, just like a cracker.